Former Pentagon analyst Michael Rubin has severely criticised Pakistan Military Chief Asim Munir over his latest ‘nuclear risk’ comment, calling him “Osama Bin Laden in a swimsuit” and stating that no quantity of concessions to Pakistan will change his ideology or that of the Pakistani elite he represents.
Pakistan Military Chief Normal Asim Munir allegedly threatened that if Pakistan “goes down, it would take half the world down” with it. The feedback had been reportedly made throughout a gathering in Tampa, Florida, with US army officers.
Rubin added that Pakistan’s risk to make use of nuclear weapons towards half the world is a transparent indication that it has misplaced its proper to be thought of a official state.
“Donald Trump is a businessman and is used to horse-trading… He doesn’t perceive {that a} unhealthy peace deal can truly advance struggle… He has the ambition to win the Nobel Peace Prize… People have a look at terrorism by the lens of grievance… Asim Munir is Osama Bin Laden in a swimsuit and there can be no quantity of concession that can be given to Pakistan that’s going to alter his ideology or the Pakistani elite he represents… The truth that Pakistan is threatening half of the world with nuclear weapons is a transparent indication that it has misplaced its proper to be a official state. It’s time for the US… to think about different insurance policies… It’s close to occasions when the long run administrations ought to enter Pakistan to safe its nuclear weapons as a result of the choice is just too nice to bear,” Rubin stated.
#WATCH | Washington DC, USA | On upcoming assembly between US and Russia, Former Pentagon official Michael Rubin says, “…Asim Munir is Osama Bin Laden in a swimsuit…”
He says, “Donald Trump is a businessman and is used to horse-trading… He doesn’t perceive {that a} unhealthy peace… pic.twitter.com/Cra1y24e19
— ANI (@ANI) August 12, 2025
Michael Rubin, a former Pentagon official and Center East analyst, advised ANI that Pakistan’s behaviour was “fully unacceptable.”
“Pakistan is elevating questions in many individuals’s minds about whether or not it could actually fulfil the duties of being a state,” Rubin stated. “The Discipline Marshal’s rhetoric is harking back to what we have heard from the Islamic State.”
Rubin known as for instant diplomatic penalties, together with stripping Pakistan of its standing as a serious non-NATO ally and doubtlessly designating it as a state sponsor of terrorism. He additionally advised that Normal Munir ought to be declared persona non grata and banned from receiving US visas.
The analyst expressed specific concern in regards to the lack of instant response from US officers current through the alleged remarks. He argued that the Pakistani military chief ought to have been instantly escorted from the assembly and expelled from the nation.
“Inside half-hour of when Asim Munir made these feedback, he ought to have been ushered out, taken to Tampa Worldwide Airport, and flown out of the US,” Rubin said.
The previous Pentagon official advised that President Trump’s continued engagement with Pakistan could be influenced by exterior elements.
He famous that Trump’s strategy represents a departure from the historically robust bipartisan assist for the US-India partnership that has developed because the George W. Bush administration.
Rubin painted a broader image of regional instability, suggesting that Pakistan’s nuclear threats may present cowl for terrorist components to “go rogue” with nuclear weapons. He argued that Pakistan represents a essentially completely different problem from conventional diplomatic disputes.
“People have a look at terrorism by the lens of grievance,” he defined. “They do not perceive the ideological underpinnings of many terrorists. Asim Munir is Osama bin Laden in a swimsuit.”
Maybe most controversially, Rubin advised that the worldwide group ought to take into account permitting Pakistan to bear what he termed a “managed decline,” doubtlessly together with recognition of breakaway areas similar to Balochistan. He even raised the potential of future army intervention to safe Pakistan’s nuclear arsenal.
“It is coming close to time when, in a future administration, different SEAL groups ought to enter Pakistan to safe its nuclear weapons as a result of the choice is just too nice to bear,” he stated.
The interview highlighted the complicated internet of relationships affecting US coverage in South Asia. Rubin advised that Trump’s latest tensions with India over commerce and sanctions associated to Russian power purchases weren’t counterproductive, noting that the US itself purchases strategic supplies from Russia.
He predicted that US-India relations would probably enhance as soon as the present administration’s strategy adjustments, describing the present tensions as a “stress take a look at” that may finally strengthen the partnership.
The analyst’s feedback mirror rising considerations about Pakistan’s stability and its nuclear capabilities. Whereas his proposals for coping with Pakistan seem to go effectively past present US coverage, they spotlight the challenges dealing with policymakers as they navigate relationships with nuclear-armed states in an more and more risky area.
(With ANI Inputs)