After Gambhir and Kotak, India batting coach provides new verdict on IND vs SA pitch row


India’s teaching employees has as soon as once more addressed the rising debate round pitch circumstances within the ongoing Take a look at collection in opposition to South Africa, with assistant coach Ryan ten Doeschate providing a measured perspective following Day 1 of the second Take a look at in Guwahati. His feedback come within the wake of criticism surrounding the Eden Gardens floor in Kolkata, the place India suffered a defeat within the opening Take a look at.

Ten Doeschate downplayed the function of the pitch in figuring out outcomes and pressured that efficiency, fairly than circumstances, should stay the first focus.

IND vs SA 2nd Take a look at Day 1: Highlights , rating card

“It is a actually powerful one. My private standpoint is that the wicket very hardly ever determines who wins the sport. If we had performed higher in Kolkata, I really feel we might have received the Take a look at on that floor. The very first thing is not to have a look at the wicket, it is to have a look at the standard of cricket each groups are enjoying,” Ten Doeschate mentioned within the press convention.

“Having mentioned that, it’s important to introspect and take a look at latest outcomes, and I believe these types of wickets possibly do go well with us a bit bit higher. You have to be ready to battle actually exhausting, and this recreation goes to go deep. The one factor I might say is that the toss turns into much more necessary in these circumstances. If you are going to lose the toss, it’s important to placed on a show like that at present and actually battle for everybody, making Be sure to keep within the recreation. Sooner or later the strain goes to come back, it is simply going to come back late on this recreation,” he added.

Ten Doeschate’s feedback got here days after head coach Gautam Gambhir confronted criticism over the Eden Gardens floor used within the first Take a look at in opposition to South Africa. The pitch had triggered a wider debate, prompting India batting coach Sitanshu Kotak to publicly defend Gambhir and dismiss options of wrongdoing, calling the backlash unfair and pushed by “particular person agendas”. In opposition to that backdrop, ten Doeschate reiterated that outcomes needs to be considered by way of the lens of efficiency fairly than circumstances.

India had been crushed within the first Take a look at in Kolkata, the place their batting struggled to adapt persistently to the floor as South Africa capitalized on key moments to take the sport away. That loss triggered debate round pitch preparation and intent.

Within the second Take a look at at Guwahati, nevertheless, issues appeared extra balanced. Appearing stand-in captain Rishabh Pant, main in Shubman Gill’s absence, misplaced the toss on Day 1, however India nonetheless managed to limit South Africa to 247 for six by stumps. Kuldeep Yadav performed an important function regardless of the pitch not being overly pleasant to spinners, ending the day with figures of three for 48 and proving that talent and management can nonetheless trump circumstances.

– ends

Revealed By:

Debodinna Chakraborty

Revealed On:

Nov 22, 2025