Simon Harmer performs down Kolkata floor criticism: Pitches on 2015 tour have been worse


South Africa off-spinner Simon Harmer has weighed in on the much-discussed pitch getting used for the continued first Check towards India at Eden Gardens in Kolkata, describing it as “so much higher” than the surfaces ready for the 2015 sequence. The Eden monitor has grow to be the middle of debate after 16 wickets fell on Day 2.

Resuming their first innings at 37 for 1, India have been bowled out for 189 in response to South Africa’s 159. The guests as soon as once more struggled to deal with the unpredictable nature of the pitch of their second innings and completed the day tottering at 93 for 7, holding a lead of solely 63 runs.

The dramatic flip of occasions triggered a wave of criticism from followers and pundits.many labeling the pitch as “unsporting”. Nonetheless, Harmers believes such criticism is misplaced, insisting that the surfaces used throughout South Africa’s 2015 tour have been considerably worse.

“The wickets in 2015 have been most likely worse. If I take into consideration the wicket in Mohali, it mainly disintegrated on day one, and Nagpur was the identical — I can keep in mind craters on the wicket. The ball has spun, nevertheless it hasn’t been each single ball. Look, India wish to win the Check match they usually wish to play on wickets that go well with them, so we have got to discover a option to beat them in their very own circumstances,” Harmer mentioned on the finish of day 2.

Harmer, who made his Check debut in 2015, performed two of the 4 Exams on that tour — in Mohali and Nagpur — each of which ended inside three days. South Africa’s administration had brazenly expressed their displeasure with the pitches throughout that sequence. Throughout the 4 innings in these two Exams, South Africa didn’t cross 200 even as soon as, whereas India’s highest complete was 215. Harmer himself claimed ten wickets, together with finest figures of 4 for 61. Persevering with his sturdy type from the Pakistan tour, he picked up 4 wickets within the first innings in Kolkata to assist dismiss India for 189.

Must get previous 100 in 4th innings: Harmer

Regardless of batting collapses from each side on this CheckHarmer stays optimistic about South Africa’s probabilities. With just one profitable fourth-innings chase of greater than 100 in Eden Gardens’ lengthy historical past, the Proteas are hoping to stretch their lead as a lot as attainable.

“I would not say I am pissed off as a result of there’s nonetheless a whole lot of cricket to be performed, and I consider we will put our greatest foot ahead and battle our option to a complete. I feel there was a stat immediately displaying there’s solely been one complete of over 100 chased within the fourth innings right here, so we have to get as many runs as we will and get previous 100. If we will get to 150, that will be unbelievable, nevertheless it’s clearly troublesome in the meanwhile, runs are laborious to come back by,” Harmer added.

There have been solely 5 profitable fourth innings chases at Eden Gardens within the stadium’s wealthy historical past. Just one rating in extra of 100 has been efficiently chased, which coincidentally got here towards South Africa in 2004 as India chased down 117 to win by eight wickets.

India not too long ago faltered whereas chasing 147 towards New Zealand at Wankhede Stadium in Mumbai, dropping by 25 runs and struggling an embarrassing 0–3 sequence whitewash. South Africa will hope to attract inspiration from that upset and finish their 15-year Check victory drought in India.

– ends

Printed By:

Rishabh Beniwal

Printed On:

Nov 15, 2025