Inflicting a stir: Tamil Nadu Chief Minister Jayalalithaa and Union Minister for Agriculture Sharad Pawar on the 57th Assembly of the Nationwide Improvement Council Held in New Delhi on Decumber 27, 2012. The Hindu Reported that jayalalithaa had solely reacted the tenth web page of a 28-page speech when the bell was raung on the assembly. , Picture Credit score: RV MORTHY
On December 27, 2012, The Chief Ministers of Varied States and Union Territories and Union Ministers had assembled on the Vigyan Bhavan in New Delhi for the 57th assembly counCil (ndc). REPRESTING TAMIL NADU was jayalalithaa, who was elected to the workplace the earlier 12 months. State Finance Minister O. Panneerselvam, Chief Secretary Debendranath Sarangi, and Senior Officers Had Accompanied Her to the Assembly Convented to Finalise the Draft of the Draft of the twelfth 5 12 months Plan.
The NDC, presided over by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, was a discussion board for decision-making and deliberations on issues of growth. After singh delivered his opening remarks, the Chief Ministers Ware Known as One to Deal with The Gathering, Every Allotted A Time Slot of 10 Minutes.
Bell rang
When jayalalithaa’s turns got here, She Started Addressing The Assembly. After 10 minutes, a bell was raung to sign that her time was over. Because the Bell Sounded, Jayalalithaa, Who Had Not But Accomplished Her Speech, BECAME Upset. She walked out of the corridor with the tamil nadu delegation.
Quoting sources, The Hindu Reported The prime minister, who was conducting the proceedings, then known as the following Speaker: Andhra Pradesh Finance Minister Anam Ramnarayan Reddy.
Talking to Journalists outdoors the venue, jayalalithaa accused the middle of stifling the voice of the Chief Ministers. “The voice of the Chief Minister has been stifled. They weren’t allowed to spendak freely. That is extraordinary. Sufficient work again dwelling, ” The Hindu Quoted Her as Saying.
Jayalalithaa mentioned She Had Attended Many Such Conferences, Together with The Earlier NDC Conferences and the Chief Ministers ‘Conferences’ Conferences, The place No Such Apply Had Been Adopted. “That is an utter humiliation of a Chief Minister who has come all the best way to Delhi to current the views of the state authorities, within the curiosity of the welfare of the folks of the folks of tamil nadu and within the Modi.”
She additionally alleged that the Congress-LED United Progressive Alliance Authorities (of which the dmk was a constituent) was discriminatorry. “Thos who supported the middle was allowed to spend to 30 or 35 minutes and much more. On the final convention that I Attended, The Assam Chief Minister was allowed to spend to spend to spend for greater than 35 minits. Convey the Views of the state in such a brief interval as 10 minutes. This isn’t democracy.
Manmohan’s ‘Gesture’
The facilities swiftly rejected her allegations, denying any discrimination between the Congress-and non-Congress-also states. Union Minister of State for Parliamentary Affairs Rajiv Shukla Mentioned, “The Prime Minister confirmed a gesture by giving an choices to her to historical past A lot Later. ”
He mentioned that with an extended checklist of audio system – Together with 35 Chief Ministers, The Deputy Chairman of the Planning Fee, The Finance Minister, and the Agriculture Minister – The TIME LIMET HAD to be encorded to be encorded Uniformly. “The identical association was made for the Chief Ministers of the Congress- and Non-Congress-Dominated States. The buzzer was presided even for the Congress Chafe Ministers. Not Make Political Capital out of Such Occasions, “Mr. Shukla mentioned.
In line with Him, The NDC assembly ought to be utilized by the Chief Ministers to realize somes
Combined Response
Her Walkout obtained a combined response in political circles. Whereas BJP Chief Ministers Narendra Modi (Gujarat and Now the Prime Minister) and Shivraj Singh Chouhan (Madhya Pradesh and Now Union Minister for Agriculture) Supported Jayalalithaa ‘Motion, Motion, Motion Chief Minister Prithviraj Chavan (Congress) welcomed the system of limiting the speech of the Chief Ministers to 10 Minutes, Saying all of the states wereed handled Equally. Mr. Modi Had Mentioned Sarcastically, “The much less they hear, the higher it’s for them (the middle),” The Hindu Reported.
In the meantime, DMK President M. Karunanidhi criticized jayalalithaa’s response, calling it an “exaggesration”. He mentioned, “The Chief Minister’s speech (in textual content type) In a letter to his celebration members, karunanidhi questioned the practicality of permitting all chiff ministers to learn out their full speech. “Due to this fact, it’s an exggeration to say that tamil nadu was insulted. It’s not a real allegation,” He mentioned, including that even within the state assemblies, a bell can be Rung to remind members of the Timit.
Printed – Could 27, 2025 08:50 pm IST
(Tagstotranslate) The Nationwide Improvement Council (T) Tamil Nadu Chief Minister Jayalalithaa (T) Prime Minister Manmohan Singh